Loading... Please wait...

The Classic Caramel Jar

The Classic Caramel Jar

Calculated at checkout

Choose Your Options


Product Description

For the Goat's Milk Caramel Enthusiast!  This 8oz jar of handcrafted goat's milk caramel is for those of you who know that a 2oz jar is not enough! Choose from our five mouthwatering flavors: Original, Salted Bourbon, Vanilla Bean, Cinnamon, Cold Brew Coffee Caramel made with Vermont Artisan Coffee Cold Brew, Spicy Dark Chocolate Caramel made with Taza Chocolate's stone ground chocolate and our NEWEST addition Vermont Maple made with Cold Hollow pure Vermont maple syrup. Our velvety goat's milk caramel sauces (Cajeta) combine creamy caramel richness with the subtle tang of goat's milk to create an utterly unique, not-too-sweet dessert sauce perfectly paired with ice cream, fruit, and cheeses.

Click HERE to learn how our caramel sauces are made, the ingredients, the process, the magic.  Click HERE to discover delicious Goat’s Milk Caramel recipes. 

Fat Toad Farm Caramel Sauces are a verified gluten-free product with a 12 month shelf life.  Jars should be refrigerated after opening. 

Don’t see the specific, super-special flavor combination you’re looking for?  Make your custom request in the comments section at check out and we’ll do our darndest to accommodate you. 

**Finish off your sweet package of Goat's Milk Caramel Sauce with our one-of-a-kind To/From cards (2"x2"). Each one shares an image from our beautiful slice of paradise up here in the Green Mountain State! All cards are randomly selected.

If you are sending the gift directly, let us know in the comment section of the checkout who we should make the gift card out to (both the "to" and "from") and which gift it should go with! 


Find Similar Products by Category

Vendors Other Products

Product Reviews

Write your own product review

  1. All natural delicious caramel 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 10th Dec 2018)

    I love caramel on ice-cream or frozen yogurt, and
    realized most have corn syrup in them. Not this one....
    it is made out of 2 ingredients: pure goat's milk and cane sugar, and the goat flavor is very mild! I prefer the original version, though the others are delicious also and personal preference.

  2. Delightful! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 3rd Dec 2018)

    This flavor is wonderful, addicting and was shipped quickly! From someone who works for a conservation organization, I especially appreciate that my order was shipped in a recycled All Birds shoe box!!! :)

  3. ORIGINAL CARAMEL 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 2nd Oct 2018)

    Without a doubt, the best caramel I have ever enjoyed!
    The goats milk puts it over the top!

  4. Simply yummy 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 26th Apr 2018)

    Fat Toad Farm produces many flavors of caramel sauce but I always come back to Classic Caramel. It is simple and pure, whether poured over vanilla ice cream or apple slices. When something is this good, I don't think it needs anything added to it. It is simply delicious.

  5. Fabulous caramel 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 2nd Dec 2017)

    A friend of mine gifted some of this caramel to me two years ago and it has become a staple in my home. I love that it stays soft enough to drizzle over anything even though its refrigerated. The goats milk flavor shines through and gives this caramel a huge advantage over plain caramel.

  6. Where do I start? 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 28th Nov 2017)

    "Where do I start? Fat Toad Farm is delicious, versatile, and a definite highlight of any breakfast bar, desert table or cheeseboard. It is creamy, pairs with pancakes, cheese, ice cream, and even simply on a spoon. You can even try a dollop in your morning coffee as a replacement to sugar and cream. As a purveyor of fine artisan American products, I have tried hundreds and hundreds of products, and as you may have guessed, not all of them are good. I can with no hesitation tell you that each and every flavor of Fat Toad Farm Goat Milk Caramel is delicious. Be creative, think outside the box, and wow your friends and family with the deliciousness. Now just imagine trying to hide in the pantry while enjoying a secret spoonful of ooey, gooey artisan goat milk caramel. I did, and I am forever changed. Thanks Fat Toad Farm for exceeding my expectations! P.S. Their customer service is top notch! Thanks again, and again!" Sincerely, DeAnna, Owner of The Traveling Cheeseboard.

    DeAnna K. B. Kent
    The Traveling Cheese Board

  7. Looooove this caramel! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 19th Sep 2017)

    I love Fat Toad Farm caramel- the quality and flavor are unparalleled. I love pouring this over gelato, along with some apples. It is the best Fall sweet treat!

  8. Awesome stuff 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 25th Dec 2016)

    My husband and I bought our first jar of Fat Toad Farm Caramel in a little store in Savannah, GA last year and have been in love with the stuff ever since. We love it so much we bought our family and friends jars for Christmas this year because we wanted to share something we love with those we love :)

  9. TASTY 4 Star Review

    (Submitted on 29th Nov 2016)

    Coffee is just a flavour that can't be beat!

  10. Amaaaaazing product!! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 14th Oct 2016)

    This caramel sauce is the very best. The Vermont Maple is to die for. It should be a staple in everyone's pantry!!

  11. Unbeleivable 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 3rd Jun 2016)

    This is the best caramel sauce i have ever tasted. I don't put it on anything. Just a couple of tablespoons and back in the frig.

  12. A review 4 Star Review

    (Submitted on 14th Oct 2015)

    I jst rec'd three different flavors of the caramel. I find the product flavorful and slightly thinner in consistency than I was expecting. Looking forward to trying it in a recipe.

  13. Toad on the Road 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 12th Oct 2015)

    Besides being a clever name for farm and products, the sticker now accompanies me on my bike helmet.
    Photo available on request.
    Oh yeah, and the caramel sauce...hmmm, more reasons to ride so I can enjoy more caramel!

  14. THE BEST! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 23rd Jun 2015)

    Years ago I found a caramel sauce, Cajeta from Mexico - being allergic to cow's milk products, this was just a wonderful find, but our local store stopped carrying it. Looked online, asked around, looked all over - with no luck. My niece gave me a jar of Fat Toad Farm Caramel Sauce and I was hooked! It was better than I remembered the sauce from Mexico was and I have ordered numerous jars since then. THANK YOU!!

  15. The BEST caramel you could ever want 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 9th Mar 2015)

    Every Fat Toad Farm caramel tastes incredible, but our favorites are Cold Brewed Coffee and Vanilla Bean. The Cold Brewed Coffee caramel mixed with a cup of whole milk, a square of dark chocolate, a tablespoon of instant espresso and warmed on the microwave for 2 minutes has become my wife's favorite coffee drink ever. She has given up her five dollar a day coffe shop " fix" for Fat Toad Farm Cold Brewed Coffee Caramel!

  16. The best caramel in the US 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 9th Nov 2014)

    This is a great product to add to your pantry. It's rich, and the milk/sugar ratio taste is delightful. The milk taste comes through and it's just sweet enough. Use it alone or over ice cream, fruit, pies, etc You can make crepes by adding chapped pecans to it. It's truly delicious. Enjoy

  17. Deliciously spicy! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 4th Sep 2014)

    The new spicy dark chocolate caramel is your best yet! You taste the dark chocolate first and gradually the kick of cayenne. It's Fabulous !

  18. Gourmet caramel sauce is liquid gold! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 23rd May 2014)

    Fat Toad Farm Vanilla Bean Caramel is simply the very best caramel you will ever taste! You have to try it to believe how amazing this stuff is. Once you do, you will be writing your own testimonial singing the praises of this lip smacking treat!

  19. creamy flavorful 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 27th Jan 2014)

    This carmel sauce is the very best I've ever had. It's creamy and flavorful. I would recommend it. It is worth the price. You can tell it is made fresh.


Click the button below to add the The Classic Caramel Jar to your wish list.