The Classic Caramel Jar (8oz)

(33 reviews) Write a Review

Our velvety goat's milk caramel sauces (Cajeta) combine creamy caramel richness with the subtle tang of goat's milk to create an utterly unique, not-too-sweet dessert sauce perfectly paired with ice cream, fruit, and cheeses. Fat Toad Farm Caramel Sauces are a verified gluten-free product with a 12 month shelf life. Jars should be refrigerated after opening.

Our Classic Caramel Jars contain 8 fluid ounces of goat's milk caramel sauce.


  • Original: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, baking soda
  • Salted Bourbon: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, Kentucky straight Bourbon, baking soda, sea salt
  • Vanilla Bean: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, baking soda, French Bourbon vanilla beans
  • Vermont Maple: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, Cold Hollow Vermont Pure Maple Syrup, baking soda
  • Cold Brew Coffee: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, Vermont Artisan Cold Brew, baking soda
  • Spicy Dark Chocolate: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, Taza Organic Stone Ground Chocolate Liquor, baking soda, ground cayenne
  • Irish Whiskey Cream: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, heavy cream, Irish Whiskey, baking soda, sea salt
  • Cinnamon: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, baking soda, organic cinnamon sticks

*Irish Whiskey Cream contains cow's cream

33 Reviews

  • 5
    I seldom purchase gourmet products without having tried a sample. So delighted I took a chance on Fat Toad Carmel. Absolutely the best I have ever tasted. Can hardly wait to share a sample with our customers. I do believe I will be a customer for

    Posted by Shirl on 15th Oct 2019

    Incredible products!!

  • 5
    Best Caramel Ever!

    Posted by Laura Price on 12th Oct 2019

    This has become our favorite caramel. You honestly can just eat it with a spoon. So creamy and amazing paired with so many things. Especially enjoy it paired with LaLoo’s Vanilla Goat Milk ice cream

  • 5
    Far Toad Farm goat milk caramel

    Posted by Diana Ainslie on 6th Oct 2019

    My daughter in law has cows milk intolerance and I buy this for desserts requiring carmelitas

  • 5
    Original Caramel

    Posted by Donna on 20th Sep 2019

    This is the best Caramel sauce in the world!! I have tasted caramel from many countries and this tops them all!

  • 5
    Wonderful, tasty product!

    Posted by Patricia Biasuzzi on 18th Sep 2019

    I recently bought two jars of this Original Caramel Sauce. My husband and I had discovered it a number of years ago and have enjoyed it ever since. This time I used some to make the recipe from your last emailing - the Caramel Apple Tart. It was delicious! Thank you so much for your special products. Today I discovered that this flavor of the Caramel Sauce, along with a few others, are sold at one of the Whole Foods stores in RI! Now if I run out, I have a source for buying it quickly! Thank you and Congratulations to You for being among the products that Whole Foods sells!

  • 5
    Cold brew coffee, cinnamon & spicy chocolate caramel

    Posted by Dolores on 11th Sep 2019

    As a repeat customer these are my fav’s. I love them in my morning coffee. Years ago when I discovered Judith’s goat milk caramel I knew that no other caramel would touch my palate. Her caramel has the perfect consistency of smoothness & it is not grossly sweet like others. Thank you Judith & your sweet goats.