The Classic Caramel Jar (8oz)

(44 reviews) Write a Review

Our velvety goat's milk caramel sauces (Cajeta) combine creamy caramel richness with the subtle tang of goat's milk to create an utterly unique, not-too-sweet dessert sauce perfectly paired with ice cream, fruit, and cheeses. Fat Toad Farm Caramel Sauces are a verified gluten-free product with a 12 month shelf life. Jars should be refrigerated after opening.

Our Classic Caramel Jars contain 8 fluid ounces of goat's milk caramel sauce.


  • Original: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, baking soda
  • Salted Bourbon: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, Kentucky straight Bourbon, baking soda, sea salt
  • Vanilla Bean: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, baking soda, French Bourbon vanilla beans
  • Vermont Maple: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, Cold Hollow Vermont Pure Maple Syrup, baking soda
  • Cold Brew Coffee: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, Vermont Artisan Cold Brew, baking soda
  • Spicy Dark Chocolate: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, Taza Organic Stone Ground Chocolate Liquor, baking soda, ground cayenne
  • Irish Whiskey Cream: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, heavy cream, Irish Whiskey, baking soda, sea salt
  • Cinnamon: Nothing but goat’s milk, pure cane sugar, baking soda, organic cinnamon sticks

*Irish Whiskey Cream contains cow's cream

44 Reviews

  • 5

    Posted by Kim on 6th Jan 2021

    I love the classic taste of this caramel sauce! I try to eat very clean foods with not a lot of ingredients so I was so happy when I found this. I love putting it on vanilla ice cream for a special treat! Yum!

  • 5
    Irish Cream caramel

    Posted by Kathy Bouvier on 27th Dec 2020

    I ordered this because I love the plain and vanilla but couldn't quite imagine how this unusual flavor would taste. Well, it IS unusual -- but also delicious! I'm dreaming up new things to pair it with, like vanilla ice cream and fruit.

  • 5
    THE BEST CARMEL IN THE 3rd dimension

    Posted by Alicia Naranjo on 22nd Dec 2020

    this is the most amazing caramel i’ve ever had!! highly recommend to anyone sitting here reading the reviews and debating if they should spend the money for a jar of caramel. well this is your sign that you should

  • 5
    Fat Toad Caramel

    Posted by Gregg Jones on 20th Dec 2020

    This was given to me as a holiday gift from a good friend and Vermont native. I, coincidentally, had sent him the SAME gift bag as I had found your company online. Our gifts literally crossed paths in the delivery! AND...this caramel is the BEST I've EVER tasted! Your products are high quality and I love supporting a family farm! Thanks!

  • 5
    Fat Toad Caramel

    Posted by BBarrett on 30th Oct 2020

    Smoothest caramel I have ever tasted! It is perfect for apple dipping!!

  • 5
    classic caramel original

    Posted by NANCY DEVRIES on 29th Oct 2020

    Seriously. this is the best caramel I've ever tasted, cooked with, and/or used as a topping. It's delightful.