Loading... Please wait...

The Classic Caramel Quartet

The Classic Caramel Quartet

Calculated at checkout

Choose Your Options


Product Description

For the Goat’s Milk Caramel Enthusiast with Friends - a quartet of 8oz jars of our creamy, handcrafted goat's milk caramel sauce.  Choose from our eight mouthwatering caramel flavors to create your ideal caramel combination: Original, Salted Bourbon, Vanilla Bean, Cinnamon, Cold Brew Coffee Caramel made with Stumptown Coffee Roasters' Cold Brew, Spicy Dark Chocolate Caramel made with Taza Chocolate's stone ground chocolate, Vermont Maple made with Cold Hollow pure Vermont maple syrup and our Limited Edition Irish Whiskey Cream*. Our velvety goat's milk caramel sauces (Cajeta) combine creamy caramel richness with the subtle tang of goat's milk to create an utterly unique, not-too-sweet dessert sauce perfectly paired with ice cream, fruit, and cheeses.

If you would prefer a different flavor combination than the options provided, please specify in the checkout comment box.

Click HERE to learn how our caramel sauces are made, the ingredients, the process, the magic.  Click HERE to discover delicious Goat’s Milk Caramel recipes. 

Fat Toad Farm Caramel Sauces are a verified gluten-free product with a 12 month shelf life.  Jars should be refrigerated after opening. 

*Our Irish Whiskey Cream uses cow's cream. 

**Finish off your sweet package of Goat's Milk Caramel Sauce with our one-of-a-kind To/From cards (2"x2"). Each one shares an image from our beautiful slice of paradise up here in the Green Mountain State! All cards are randomly selected.

If you are sending the gift directly, let us know in the comment section of the checkout who we should make the gift card out to (both the "to" and "from") and which gift it should go with! 



Find Similar Products by Category

Product Reviews

Write your own product review

  1. Perfect for a gift 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 12th Nov 2015)

    Something a little better and unusual for one nice
    gift or several small ones. (You will want to keep one jar at least.)

  2. THE best caramel! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 1st Nov 2015)

    I am in love, LOVE, with this caramel. The cold brew coffee flavor is by far the best caramel I've ever had in my life. Hand me the epic jar and a straw. Fun packaging and excellent customer service to boot. I bought jars for all my friends and family for the holidays. Cheers!

  3. Never order just one! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 30th Oct 2015)

    This is pure liquid gold. Never order just one. They are oh so handy to keep on hand for gifting friends and family on special occasions. The assortment of flavors is astounding and great incentive to try more!

  4. EXCELLENT!!!!!! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 28th Oct 2015)

    I bought this set of four for my father's birthday. He is in love with the caramel flavors I picked. It turned out to be a great gift!!!!!

  5. Best Caramel On The Planet!! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 19th Oct 2015)

    Creamy, delicate with depth, there is literally nothing better. I'm hooked!!!!

  6. We love it! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 7th Jul 2015)

    We ordered the sample jars first and loved every flavor so this time I ordered the regular size jar! Safe to say we will be Fat Toad customers from now on!

  7. Beautiful! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 8th Jun 2015)

    I bought my first jar of Fat Toad Farm through a promotion on The Republic of Tea website, and I knew when I finished the jar I had to get more. My first jar was Original, and now having tried other flavors it's clear that the flavor ingredients are chosen carefully to be of the same superior caliber as the caramel itself. I put it mostly in tea and coffee, but I'll definitely be trying some of the recipes that were included in my box. It's that kind of touch that makes me appreciate small businesses: they clearly love the product they make, and want to share that love with you.

  8. no other caramel needed! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 5th Jun 2015)

    Fat Toad Farm has the tastiest, most incredible product I've ever tried. Having grown up eating "dulce de leche" in south america, I can appreciate the love and care that goes into it... Not to mention consistency and taste! Wow! This product is one that has me and my husband recommending it to anyone we know!

  9. love. love. love 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 1st Jun 2015)

    Love them alld

  10. The best ever 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 25th May 2015)

    When I found Fat Toad Farm Caramel, I was amazed at the flavor & the fact that it wasn't overly sweet. To be honest I will never eat any other brand of caramel. Now about the flavors they are all my favorites, but the new Spicy Dark Chocolate really rocks my taste buds, love it in coffee.

  11. Best caramel of all time! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 7th May 2015)

    I have tried a lot of different caramels and Fat Toad Farm is by far the best! And I can't pick which flavor is my favorite they are all so good!


    (Submitted on 7th Apr 2015)

    Love Fat Toad Caramel!!! Picked up a small container at my local whole foods and have been hooked since!!! Salted bourbon is my favorite flavor of them all. How could you just buy one?? The quartet is a must have. Do it!

  13. My Obsession... 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 27th Feb 2015)

    This winter has been tough but you know what's making it tolerable? Fat Toad Farm caramel sauce! I adore your product and I have shared it with all my friends and family. The quality is exceptional.

  14. The best ever and my fave 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 22nd Dec 2014)

    I love this Spicy Dark Chocolate, it puts sass in my coffee. This is my new fave, dark chocolate & spicy kick is what I add to my coffee every morning. A must have in my house. I'll pass on the cream & sweetener, just give me my Spicy Dark Chocolate. Thanks Judith for the best caramel ever.

  15. You won't find better caramel ~ 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 15th Dec 2014)

    We have a large family and trying to make everyone happy is almost impossible...except when it comes to Fat Toad Farms Caramel sauces. Because of the amazing taste and selection, I know that when I order from them that ever single person in my family will be happy (even if it is only for the duration of dessert!)

    I give them as gifts, and I am thanked profusely from the families as they fall in love with them as well.

    Thanks for all of your hard work in producing such a fabulous product. You literally have a customer for life in me :)

  16. Best Caramel found anywhere 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 8th Dec 2014)

    I can't begin to tell you how excited I was to taste this caramel. From the very first bite it took me completely by surprise! I was expecting a nice sweet taste to go with a panna cotta I had made, instead I got a fantastic pop of unexpected magic, the creamy texture and flavor cannot be compared. I must keep ordering this because nothing else will ever hold a candle.

  17. #chubbygirlcrack 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 19th Aug 2014)

    If you had peeked into my kitchen window last night you would have witnessed the unthinkable. Up to the second knuckle in a jar of divine cinnamon caramel from Fat Toad Farm. So far I've tried the Vanilla, Classic, Salted Bourbon, and Cinnamon varieties. Can't wait to try the chocolate and coffee!

    The caramel is perfection. Its not too sweet and it stays a great consistency when put in the fridge. You know when you want caramel RIGHT NOW and don't want to have to wait for it to soften up to the pouring temperature. No problem. This stuff delivers when you need it most!

    I've used it on pears (divine), ice cream, pretzels, cookies, cakes, shortcake, pointer finger, middle finger, ring finger...In my hot coffee, iced lattes!

    Get it, try it, gotta have it. Got to share it! When they have the sales - stock up! Great as a gift. And I LOVE all the little recipe cards they send with the order.

    I'm an addict. Happily.

  18. More reasons to eat fruit 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 16th Aug 2014)

    This caramel arrived on the same day I had gone shopping at Fresh Market and came back with a bunch of apples. Needless to say, we tested out each and every one of these delicious jars of gooey goodness and fell in love with each one. There is no "best" one to tell you about as they are all outstanding. We plan on buying more and more as the months go on and including them in with some gifts for our clients. Thanks for being such a wonderful farm and making the best goat milk caramel EVER!

  19. Delicious and versatile treat! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 12th May 2014)

    My husband and I discovered Fat Toad Farm caramel sauces a year ago and now they are a most favorite treat. We like all of the flavors but the Original is the one we go to most often. These sauces are silky, very rich tasting and can be used in so many interesting ways. Besides just enjoying a plain spoonful, a simple dessert for us is some vanilla frozen yogurt topped with the caramel sauce. Sometimes we add crushed nuts or a small crushed butter cookie on top. YUM! We were able to visit the farm last fall during a trip to Vermont. We truly enjoyed our tour, saw the production operation, met some of the friendly, hard working staff, and were curiously greeted by several of the very endearing goats. It was a great experience and we thank everyone at the farm and all of the happy goats whose milk makes these sauces possible.


Click the button below to add the The Classic Caramel Quartet to your wish list.