Loading... Please wait...

The Classic Caramel Duo

The Classic Caramel Duo

Calculated at checkout

Choose Your Options


Product Description

For the Goat’s Milk Caramel Enthusiast Who Loves to Share!  One jar for you and one for a friend.  ...or two just for you?  Either way, enjoy two 8oz jars of our handcrafted goat's milk caramel sauces in your favorite combination of flavors: Original, Salted Bourbon, Vanilla Bean, Cinnamon, Cold Brew Coffee Caramel made with Stumptown Coffee Roasters' Cold Brew, Spicy Dark Chocolate Caramel made with Taza Chocolate's stone ground chocolate, Vermont Maple made with Cold Hollow pure Vermont maple syrup, and our Limited Edition Irish Whiskey Cream*. Our velvety goat's milk caramel sauces (Cajeta) combine creamy caramel richness with the subtle tang of goat's milk to create an utterly unique, not-too-sweet dessert sauce perfectly paired with ice cream, fruit, and cheeses.

Click HERE to learn how our caramel sauces are made, the ingredients, the process, the magic.  Click HERE to discover delicious Goat’s Milk Caramel recipes. 

Fat Toad Farm Caramel Sauces are a verified gluten-free product with a 12 month shelf life.  Jars should be refrigerated after opening. 

*Our Irish Whiskey Cream uses cow's cream. 

**Finish off your sweet package of Goat's Milk Caramel Sauce with our one-of-a-kind To/From cards (2"x2"). Each one shares an image from our beautiful slice of paradise up here in the Green Mountain State! All cards are randomly selected.

If you are sending the gift directly, let us know in the comment section of the checkout who we should make the gift card out to (both the "to" and "from") and which gift it should go with! 

Find Similar Products by Category

Product Reviews

Write your own product review

  1. Our favorite product for gifts - and for our family! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 3rd Jan 2016)

    We are devoted to Fat Toad caramel sauces, all of them! And especially VT Maple and Salted Bourbon, which we use on ice cream or toast, and sometimes straight up. Our go-to dessert for dinner parties, and for holiday gifts: perfect! Also love the logo, as well as the story of Fat Toad farm, a local business that is inspiring in so many ways.

  2. Mmmmmmmmm 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 20th Nov 2015)

    I think this is the best caramel I have ever had. I keep talking about how good it would be on this or that and then can't bring myself to add anything that might dilute or distract from the flavor.

  3. Delicious as always! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 11th Jul 2015)

    My husband and I discovered Fat Toad Farm's caramel sauces a few years ago. Now we consider them a most delicious treat as they are consistently tasty plus they add a feeling of decadence to whatever they accompany. We have visited the farm and met some of the goats which was fun. So I think of them and also the humans who are involved in the production of the sauces and thank them all for their hard work and dedication. These sauces make the dreariest day seem a little brighter!

  4. Beyond Delicious 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 28th Jun 2015)

    Mesmerizing texture and taste by the spoonful, and blew my mind as an apple crisp topping. Love the maple!

  5. Heavenly! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 7th May 2015)

    this caramel made my day! It tastes so good on anything or by the spoonful. For someone allergic to everything like me, this has been a sweet blessing I can enjoy!!

  6. Simply the best ... 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 7th Apr 2015)

    As I live in Vermont, this is not my first batch of Fat Road Caramel. Each and every time I open a new jar, I am surprised how wonderful it is. Friends ask, what do I put Fat Toad Caramel on, and my answer is always the same, a spoon!

    Creamy, velvety but never too sweet, the best.

  7. Yummy caramel!! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 31st Jan 2015)

    I'm so excited to receive your caramel again. I have used it for baking and your caramel really makes the difference. I have this recipe calling for a caramel topping and the first time I made the recipe, I used your product.. I have mad the recipe three times since and it is just not the same. I don't think I will ever make it again without using your caramel.. Thanks so much. it's worth every cent!

  8. wonderful 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 23rd Nov 2014)

    Absolutely addicting! Very versatile in many recipes and superb on its own. Well worth the money.

  9. deliciousness in a jar! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 5th Oct 2014)

    The new maple caramel is a taste of fall. Keep the delicious flavored coming!

  10. Bombdigity! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 25th Jul 2014)

    This stuff is great! I have tried other brands and this is the best thus far! Love it!

  11. If you LOVE caramel 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 24th Jul 2014)

    Simply scrumptious! Creamy. Just the perfect blend of caramel flavors. My first purchase and I'm hooked.

  12. Love the flavors in this duo 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 14th Jul 2014)

    I love caramel. Period. When you find great caramel it's a day to celebrate. This is great caramel. My only wish is for it to be carried in a local market. Thank goodness for the internet and online shopping.

  13. Banana Cajeta Ice Cream 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 23rd Jun 2014)

    I was introduced to Fat Toad Farms Cajeta last spring when it was used in a Jeni's Ice Cream. It was one of my favorite flavors of all time. I recently had an ice cream social and I replicated Jeni's Banana Cajeta. It was the favorite of my guests. The Cajeta is sweet, tangy, and a little expected.

  14. Luscious! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 9th Jun 2014)

    This caramel sauces are heavenly! I am so glad I found products that are both delicious and have reasonable calorie counts. Another wonderful thing is that they are all natural, with no artifical, chemical ingredients, especially that "caramel color" that is a dangerous additive, present in so many foods today. I am definitely a customer for life and will try the other flavors!

  15. AMAZING! 5 Star Review

    (Submitted on 19th Nov 2013)



Click the button below to add the The Classic Caramel Duo to your wish list.